阿道夫·希特勒(Adolf Hitler)——欧美史上十大哑巴

阿道夫希特勒欧美史上十大哑巴在欧美史上十大哑巴中排名第13名。

·······································································

我们精选了部分网友观点：

···································································

谁把这个放在名单上的？一个犹太人谁是历史上的白痴？这个人在令人费解的创纪录的时间里征服了近20个国家！他制造了第一架喷气式飞机他制造了第一枚智能炸弹他制造了第一枚弹道导弹，这也是进入太空的第一个物体他制造了世界上最好的潜艇制造了世界上第二好的坦克老虎坦克如果他不为大屠杀负责的话，他会被称为有史以来最聪明的人！-路易斯普拉多

Who put this on the list? A Jewish person who is an idiot in history? This man conquered close to 20 countries in a baffling record time!He made the first jet airplaneHe made the first smart bombHe made the first ballistic missile, which was also the first object into spaceHe made the worlds best submarineHe made the worlds second best tank-The Tiger TankIf he wasn't responsable for the Holocaust he would be called the smartest person EVER! - luisprado

···································································

路易斯说得很好，但在我看来大屠杀从来没有发生过

*Claps* Well said Luis but the Holocaust never happened *In my opinion* - CerealGuy

···································································

-我们所说的是一个非常不稳定的狂躁性格，他身边有一些杰出的军事头脑和工程师，例如沃纳·冯·布劳恩——他在国家安全与发展计划下的法西斯政权中成长，没有太多选择——另一个例子：第一个喷气式飞机的概念是在战争爆发前由英国皇家空军军官提出的，三十多岁。这与希特勒无关。-在一个极权独裁统治下，你可以强迫任何人为你工作，你是他那个时代最杰出的德国天才，然后让人们相信他自己制造这些东西是为了加入“个人崇拜”。-据许多报道，事实上，他并不像有些人想相信的那么聪明，我还要补充一点，在某件事上一心一意的狂热并不是学术或“聪明”思维的特征。请在发表这种胡言乱语之前先去学习，我不介意，但我不介意有人买它。——迪尔胡特1984

- We are talking about a very unstable manic personality that had some brilliant military minds and engineers at his side (Werner Von Braun e.g. -who didn't have much of a choice growing up in a fascist regime under the NSDP)- Another example: the first concept of a jet airplane was made by an RAF officer before the war broke out, mid-thirties. It has nothing to do with Hitler.- In a totalitarian dictatorship you can force anyone to work for you, the most brilliant German geniuses of his time, and then let the people believe he made those things himself to add to the "persona cult".- according to many reports, he wasn't actually that smart as some would want to believe, and I'd add to that that being that single-minded and fanatic in something is not a characteristic of academic or "smart" thinking.Please go study before posting such rambling nonsense, I don't mind, but I do mind some people buy it. - Deerhunter1984

···································································

你的评论很搞笑，而且在很多方面都有缺陷。我允许我自己指出你的逻辑谬误，代之以向读者提供一些事实。-喷气式飞机的第一个概念是30年代中期英国皇家空军军官设计的，当然不是希特勒设计的，更不用说他是一个航空航天工程师。第一枚弹道导弹，纳粹德国使用的V-2火箭是沃纳·冯·布劳恩制造的，垂直发射时，它的最高高度达到了206公里128英里，能够到达太空。希特勒选择了冯·布劳恩自20世纪20年代以来发展起来的概念，因为他在战争目的的研究上投入了大量资金，显然他自己也不懂制造这种导弹。第一艘服役的潜艇是基于一个爱尔兰发明家的概念，1900年左右被美国海军使用荷兰六世，也在1904年的日俄战争和后来的第一次世界大战期间，潜艇被广泛使用。德国的潜艇不是独一无二的，但在当时非常好，在第二次世界大战期间，可以说是在某些特定的时刻占据统治地位。但是没有一个理智的人会声称独裁者是自己制造潜艇的。-他身边有军事天才，当然，他身边还有沃纳·冯·布劳恩和一些可以说非常聪明的人，但作为一个极权主义纳粹独裁者，他当然可以给人们留下不多的东西一个选择和招募每一个有用的德国人来包围他最聪明的发明家。这与希特勒的智力无关。——根据许多历史学家和精神病专家的说法，根据第一手目击者、著作、录像等，希特勒不仅从一开始就有狂躁的个性，即使是未受过训练的人也会得出，但他患有偏执性精神分裂症和歇斯底里的自大狂https:+/+/www.psycologytoday.com+/blog+/邪恶行为+/201412+/希特勒有多疯狂想想看，当战争转向有利于盟军的时候，许多绝望的游击队式的战争行为。年轻的德国士兵和他派来的希特勒青年士兵在阿登的绝境反击中死而复生，他命令他在被占领的巴黎的将军在全军覆没的情况下烧毁这座城市，幸运的是他是确信如果希特勒的精神错乱和另一场悲剧得以避免。——最重要的是，没有任何细微差别，没有黑白对比、善与恶、优等与劣等种族的思考，很难被看作是任何一个聪明人的特征，离一个有才华的学术头脑也很遥远。对不起我的英语，但我希望我能帮助这个社区，因为看到这条评论有90张赞成票，我感到很不安，并且在这个网站上讲述了一些投票公众的状况，年轻人是多么容易受到评论的影响，挖掘他们的挫败感，而不是受到历史事实和理性的启发。我希望你有很多的研究和一个好的学位。你的真诚。—迪尔亨特1984

Your comment is hilarious and flawed in many ways. I shall allow myself to point out your logical fallacies and instead provide the reader with some facts.- The first concept of a Jet Airplane was engineered by an RAF officer in the mid-thirties, of course not by Hitler, let alone that he was an aerospace engineer (lol).-The first ballistic missile, the V-2 Rocket used by Nazi Germany was made by Werner von Braun it reached indeed a max. altitude of 206 km (128miles) when launched vertically, being able to reach space. Hitler chose his concepts von Braun had developed since the 20's because he invested heavily in research for war purposes obviously he had no hand nor any understanding of making such missiles himself.- The first commissioned submarine was based on a concept of an Irish inventor and used by the US Navy around 1900 (the Holland VI), also during the Russo-Japanese War of 1904 and later World War I, submarines as you would know them were extensively used. The German submarines were not unique, but very good at the time, and arguably dominating at certain points during WW2. But no sane person would ever claim that the dictator made submarines himself.- He was surrounded by military geniuses and of course he had Werner Von Braun and some arguably very intelligent people at his side, but as a totalitarian Nazi-dictator he could of course leave people not much of a choice and recruit every German of use to surround him with the brightest inventors. This has nothing to do with Hitler's intelligence.- According to many historians and psychiatrists and based on first-hand witnesses, writings, footage etc..., Hitler not only had a manic personality from the start, as even the untrained could derive, but he suffered from paranoid schizophrenia and hysterical megalomania (https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/evil-deeds/201412/how-mad-was-Hitler). Think of the many desperate (guerrilla-like) war acts when the war had turned in favor of the Allies. Young German soldiers (and 'child' soldiers from the Hitler jugend) he sent do their certain death in desperate counter-strikes around the Ardennes, and he ordered his general in occupied Paris to burn down the city when all was lost, luckily he was convinced if Hitler's insanity by a number of diplomats and another tragedy prevented.- Most importantly, being devoid of any nuance and thinking in black white, good vs evil, superior race vs. other inferior races, can hardly be seen as a characteristic of any intelligent person and couldn't be further away from a talented academic mind.Sorry for my English but I hope I helped this community because seeing this comment had 90 upvotes, I felt it troubling and telling something about the state of the voting public on this site, and how easily young people are influenced by comments tapping into their feelings of frustration rather than getting inspired by historical facts and reason. I wish you lots of studies and a good degree.Yours sincerely. - Deerhunter1984

···································································

他试图在冬天入侵俄罗斯，拿破仑又一次向苏联宣战，而不是把他的军事力量集中在不列颠群岛上，在这种情况下，他几乎肯定会赢得战争。他试图接管斯大林格勒，只是为了给它改名为希特勒堡。他向美国宣战，美国是一个巨大而强大的敌人，就因为日本这么做了。他解雇了所有的将军，让几乎不懂军事战略的希姆莱掌管他的大部分军队。他相信耶稣是雅利安人，尽管他是犹太人

He tried to invade Russia in the winter (napoleon all over again)He declared war on the USSR instead of focusing his military might on the british isles, in which case he almost certainly would have won the war.He tried to take over Stalingrad just so he could re name it Hitlerburg.He declared war on the United States, a huge and powerful enemy, just because Japan did.He fired all of his generals and put Himmler, who knew almost nothing about military strategy, in charge of much of his army.He believed jesus was Aryan even though he was Jewish.

···································································

你的大部分观点都是有道理的，除了2。虽然他的决定可能有点草率，但背后有原因。希特勒知道苏联不会容忍法西斯在欧洲的完全统治，最终会对他宣战，所以他想在这一切发生之前，出其不意地采取行动，希特勒根本不可能入侵不列颠群岛。当时的英国海军是世界上最大的，比他的海军要大得多，而试图海军登陆基本上就像把他的战舰踩进火山一样。——库奇英雄

Most of your points are somewhat valid, except for #2.While his decisions might have been a bit rash, there was a reason behind them. Hitler knew the USSR would not tolerate complete fascist dominance in Europe and would eventually declare war on him anyways, so he wanted to take them by surprise before that could happen.As well, Hitler never could have invaded the British Isles. The British Navy at the time was the largest in the world, much larger than his, and attempting a naval landing would be basically like trowing his ships into a volcano. - TheCookieHero

···································································

希特勒不是哑巴。他是历史上最强大的独裁者之一。希特勒知道德国人正在寻找一个替罪羊来解释为什么他们第一次世界大战失败了，并说服他们，正是犹太人毁灭了他们的国家。当他得到“纯德国人”的支持时，他会去命令犹太人离开这个国家，后来又下令处死他们。他可能是个邪恶的独裁者，但他绝非哑巴。如果希特勒是个哑巴，他可能根本就不会写一本关于他憎恨犹太人的书

Hitler is NOT dumb. He was one of history's strongest dictators. Hitler knew Germans were looking for a scapegoat for why they lost WWI, and convinced them that is was the Jewish population that ruined their country. The moment he got the "pure Germans" on his side, he would go to order Jews to leave this country, and later ordered their deaths. He may have been an evil dictator, but he was far from dumb. If Hitler were dumb, he probably would've never even wrote a book about his hatred of the Jews.

···································································

在愚蠢和聪明之间有一条很好的界限，而希特勒虽然我不太欣赏他，但在我看来，他是居中的。这只是一个观点，不要太认真，但我真的认为他是愚蠢的试图杀死所有这些人。他是愚蠢的试图接管，他是聪明到足以使吨吨伟大的发明本可以用来帮助无辜者而不是杀死他们

There is a fine line between stupid and smart, and Hitler (even though I don't really appreciate him) is right in the middle in my opinion. This is just an opinion, don't take this too seriously, but I really do think he is stupid for trying to kill all of these people. He's stupid for trying to take over, and he was smart enough to make TONS of great inventions that could've been used to HELP innocents instead of killing them all.

···································································

他是英雄，是所有伟大领袖的偶像。我们需要更多像他一样的领袖！前一件事显然不是我的真实看法，但他并不愚蠢，因为他为自己的国家做了比我们任何一位“伟大的总统”都能为我们做的更多的事情。他把德国从坟墓里救了回来，他几乎干掉了所有反对他的人。但他没有学习和攻击苏联，也从来没有攻击过俄罗斯

Not stupid he is a hero and an Idol to all great leaders out there. We need more Leaders like him Heil!Jk that previous thing is obviously not my true opinion, But he is not stupid as he did more for his country than any of our "Great Presidents" can do for ours. He brought Germany back from the Grave and he accomplished to nearly take out all who oppose him. But he did not learn and Attacked Russia (Soviet Union. Never attack Russia.

···································································

他比世界上所有人都笨。他是世界上最蠢的人。他是有史以来最蠢的人。他操纵人类是因为他太笨了。他应该在这个名单上排名更高。希特勒比这个星球上的任何人都笨，从来没有

He was dumber than all other people in the world. He is the dumbest person in the world. He is the dumbest person of all time. He manipulated humans because he was too dumb. He should higher on this list. Hitler is dumber than everyone on this planet, ever.