迈克·波特诺伊（梦幻剧场，液体张力实验(Mike Portnoy (Dream Theater, Liquid Tension Experi)——欧美十佳金属鼓手

迈克波特诺伊梦幻剧场液体张力实验欧美十佳金属鼓手在欧美十佳金属鼓手中排名第1名。

迈克尔·波特诺伊是一位美国鼓手，最初被称为前鼓手、伴唱，是进步金属/摇滚乐队梦想剧场的联合创始人。波特诺伊以其鼓手的技术技能而闻名，他曾获得《现代鼓手》杂志颁发的30个奖项。

·······································································

Michael Portnoy is an American drummer primarily known as the former drummer, backing vocalist, and a co-founder of the progressive metal/rock band Dream Theater. Known for his technical skill as a drummer, Portnoy has won 30 awards from the Modern Drummer magazine.

·······································································

我们精选了部分网友观点：

···································································

乔伊·乔迪森和牧师在名单上干什么？乔伊·乔迪森被高估了，躲在触发器后面。如果牧师在一个更好的乐队里（他以巨大的优势超过了a7x）他仍然不比迈克·波特诺伊、迈克·曼吉尼、戴夫·伦巴多、吉恩·霍格兰、托马斯·哈克、乔治·科利亚斯、文尼·保罗、丹尼·凯里、比尔·沃德、马里奥·杜普兰蒂埃、马丁·洛佩兹、布兰恩·戴勒，史考特·特拉维斯，克里斯·阿德勒，维吉尔·多纳蒂等等。这个名单是个笑话。在“杀戮者”一节里哪个笨蛋说“杀戮者”不是主流。你真的是真的吗？你知道，他们在四巨头中是有原因的。约翰·多尔马扬比乔治·科利亚斯强？我不想再活下去了

People who think Lars Ulrich is the best probably don't even know who Mike Portnoy is. If you haven't listened to Dream Theater you definitely should. +++Well I listen to Dream Theater so I know who he his.

···································································

当你点击最佳金属鼓手名单，看到你最喜欢的人排在第一位，这是一种非常奇妙的感觉。迈克在我的个人生活中为我做了很多事情（在他的工作和对梦幻剧场的坚持以及梦剧院为我做了多少事）而在我的鼓声中，没有迈克，我将远远不及现在的水平，他的鼓声激励了我不仅是为了打鼓，更是为了享受它。每次我演奏八度音阶，是的，鼓上的一切都有一些令人难以置信的东西。他的鼓声和个性充满了活力和华丽，如果没有他，梦幻剧场从来都不一样。我喜欢迈克·曼吉尼斯的演奏，但他缺少迈克·波特诺伊·布兰对乐队的那种额外元素。绝对是第一名——本里德100

He can drum according to the songs mood. He is not hammering the drum when playing smooth DT songs. He is not being slow when playing aggressive DT songs. Versatility is what DT and its band members all about.

···································································

迄今为止最好的金属鼓手。我想提到他在金属鼓手方面的其他竞争对手，以下是我的前10名：1.迈克·波特诺伊（梦幻剧场）2.戴夫·伦巴多（杀戮者）3.托马斯·哈克（梅苏加饰）4.丹尼·凯里（工具）5.乔伊·乔迪森（斯莱普克诺特）6.比尔·沃德（黑人萨巴斯）7.尼科·麦克布莱恩（铁娘子）8.温妮·保罗（潘泰拉）9.拉尔斯·乌尔里奇（金属片）10.约翰·多尔梅扬（系统倒下）（同时，我想澄清一下，我没有把尼尔·皮尔特列入这个名单的唯一原因是，我不认为拉什是任何接近金属的东西，这不是因为我认为他不好，事实上他是有史以来最好的鼓手之一，我只是不认为他是金属鼓手。只是想把这一点跨越）

mike he is the best... his drumming is just so ammazing... no one else got the talent like he does in drumming field...

···································································

首先……迈克·波特诺伊是有史以来入选现代鼓手名人堂的最年轻的人。看看名单上还有谁……MP是唯一的金属鼓手。迈克实际演奏的是疯狂的，永恒之舞比其他任何人都要疯狂。我不是他的现场鼓独奏，但其中一些是相当酷的。他使用奇怪的时间签名是致命的，他使用的效果钹在非拍子和口音只是不真实的（例如6:00简介）

First of all... Mike Portnoy is the youngest person ever inducted into the Modern Drummer Hall of Fame. Just take a look at who else is on that list... MP is the only metal drummer on there. What mike actually plays is insane, the dance of eternity is crazier that anything anybody else on this list has done. I'm not a huge fan of his live drum solos but some of them are pretty cool. His use of odd-time signatures is deadly, and his use of effects cymbals on off beats and accents are just unreal

···································································

我记得我第一次听迈克·波特诺（Mike Portnoy）（醒着的专辑，我敢肯定这首歌是6:00）我的嘴和眼睛都睁得大大的。我是拉尔斯·乌尔里奇（Lars Ulrich）和尼科·麦克布莱恩（Nicko Mc Brain fan）的粉丝，工具非常喜欢我，虽然我听过的鼓手比我的老鼓手还快，但我还是很喜欢他的鼓手，新的金属乐迷必须倾听老乐队的声音，把他们的前十名排得更好。雷夫很容易进入前十名，但波特尼必须是第一名！约翰·兰格尔以前的PoS鼓手怎么样了？一个被低估的鼓手！兰格尔一定也进了前十名！

Look, I love Avenged Sevenfold and admire The Rev to the greatest extent, in fact, I consider The Rev an inspiration to me, being a drummer, but Mike is just OUTSTANDING! He's like a drum god! Don't believe me? Listen to ANY Dream Theater song or the Avenged Sevenfold album "Nightmare". As much as I WANT to vote for The Rev, I have to admit Mike is better. Nothing personal, Jimmy...

···································································

你看，我爱复仇七倍和佩服牧师，事实上，我认为牧师是一个鼓舞我，作为一个鼓手，但迈克是优秀的！他就像个鼓神！不相信我？听任何一首梦幻剧场歌曲或《复仇七倍》专辑《噩梦》。尽管我很想投票给牧师，但我必须承认迈克比他更好。没有什么私人的，吉米

It is such an amazing feeling to click on a best metal drummers list and see your favourite at number 1. Mike has done so much for me in my personal life (in his work and perseverance in Dream Theater and how much Dream Theater has done for me) and in my drumming, I would be nowhere near as good as I am now without Mike, his drumming inspired me not only to play drums but to enjoy it. Every time I play Octavarium, yes the whole thing on the drums there is just something about it which is just in

···································································

我很尊敬戴夫·隆巴多，但他缺乏迈克·波特诺伊一般的多才多艺。A7X的粉丝们，我有一些坏消息……是的，牧师是一个伟大的鼓手，但他远不及迈克和戴夫那样的传奇人物。拉尔斯也是一样的，所有的金属鼓手都必须是伟大的鼓手，但拉尔斯只是一点点，但超过了伟大。乔伊乔迪森是一个伟大的鼓手，但他应该在名单的倒数10名

What the hell is joey jordison and the rev doing on this list? Joey jordison is overrated and hides behind triggers. The Rev might have ended up better if he was in a better band (he outclassed a7x by a huge margin) He's still not better than Mike portnoy, Mike Mangini, Dave Lombardo, Gene Hoglan, Thomas Haake, George Kollias, Vinny paul, Danny Carey, Bill Ward, Mario Duplantier, Martin Lopez, Brann Dailor, Scott Travis, Chris Adler, Vergil Donati and many more. This List is a joke. And What ret

···································································

听迈克·波特诺伊打鼓，让我想起了尼尔普·拉什，在整首歌中，能把节奏从柔和和缓慢变为硬朗和快速，真是太棒了！在复仇七倍失去了牧师，谁是另一个踢屁股鼓手…他们把迈克带来了…这本身就说明了很多，乐队也相信迈克的可怕的才华！

Listening to Mike Portnoy playing the drums, reminds me of Neil P. Of Rush. The abilities to change up the tempo, from soft and slow to hard and fast, throughout songs, is amazing! After Avenged Sevenfold lost the Rev, who was another kick ass drummer... They brought Mike on board... That says a lot in itself, that the band also believed in Mike's awesome talents!

···································································

老实说，排在第一位的应该是波尔图或伦巴多，但作为一名DT球迷，这家伙是个英雄。他的节奏很有趣，技术上也很激烈，他能像其他鼓手一样随心所欲地营造气氛。如果你对为什么这个人应该排在第一位有任何疑问，那就好好对待自己，听听你父亲的荣耀，并以天啊，你的脑子会被炸飞的

By far the best metal drummer of all time. I want to mention his other competitors in metal drumming, so here is my top 10:

1. Mike Portnoy (Dream Theater)

2. Dave Lombardo (Slayer)

3. Thomas Haake (Meshuggah)

4. Danny Carey (Tool)

5. Joey Jordison (Slipknot)

6. Bill Ward (Black Sabath)

7. Nicko McBrain (Iron Maiden)

8. Vinnie Paul (Pantera)

9. Lars Ulrich (Metallica)

10. John Dolmayan (System Of A Down)

(Also, I want t

···································································

迈克应该是第一个！我是说你听过他演奏吗？！老实说，我看了他们中最好的鼓手，但我看了他们所有的歌曲，我觉得是不同的！我不知道他为什么要退出梦幻剧场…很棒的乐队，但现在已经不一样了..表现出更多的评论；

I highly respect dave lombardo, but he lacks the general versatility of Mike Portnoy. A7X fans, I've got some bad news... Yes the Rev was a great drummer, but he's nowhere near the legends that mike and dave are. Lars is the same thing, all metal drummers need to be great drummers, but Lars is only a little but above great. Joey Jordison is a great drummer, but he should be towards the bottom 10 on the list.