M、 夏玛兰之夜(M. Night Shyamalan)——欧美史上最差的电影导演

夏玛兰之夜欧美史上最差的电影导演在欧美史上最差的电影导演中排名第3名。

·······································································

我们精选了部分网友观点：

···································································

很明显，讨厌这家伙的作品的人和那些欣赏他的作品的人之间存在着很大的分歧。好吧，他也许在第六感中有过一次伟大的成功，但之后就成了一次又一次的垃圾。最新的例子是《最后的气宗》。只要在youtube上观看电视节目的片段就知道了，这部电影非常有创意，也很受欢迎。为了拓宽自己的类型，他彻底抹杀了本来可以是一部很有娱乐性和喜剧性的电影，取而代之的是我一生中看过的最无聊、最无生气的电影。这部电影唯一的特点是视觉效果，但对话和传达，电影的节奏，以及关于电影方向的其他一切都是直截了当的糟糕和侮辱

Apparently there is a big divide between people who hate this guy's work, and those that um, appreciate it. Okay he might have had one great hit in the Sixth Sense, but after that it's been garbage after garbage. The latest example being The Last Airbender. Just watch clips of the T.V. show on youtube to see how funny, brilliantly creative, and popular the show is. In trying to broaden his genre, he completely massacres what could have been a great entertaining and comedic movie, and instead dishes out the most boring and lifeless movie I ever watched in my life. The only thing about that movie was the visual effects, but the dialogues, the deliveries, the pacing of the film, and everything else about the direction of the film was flat out bad and insulting.

···································································

我不认为沙马兰是一个完全不好的电影制作人。当然，他多年来拍了很多糟糕的电影，但很明显这个人有一定的天赋。在他早期的职业生涯中，他的电影很好。他们的水平各不相同，但他们仍然表现出很多技巧、技巧和智慧。然而，我不是否认像《最后的风宗》、《发生》、《地球之后》这样的电影，《水中的女人》真是糟透了。这些电影从无聊到无心的搞笑都有。看来M.Night正在把自己挖出来。这次访问很不错，斯普利特也很不错。我希望这家伙能继续成功，不仅仅因为他是费城人，还因为他在每一部电影中都尝试过。他不像迈克尔·贝或萨尔茨·弗里德伯格那样，他们根本不在乎电影的质量。很明显，希亚玛兰是一个狂热的电影爱好者。更多-费城体育

I do not believe that Shyamalan is an altogether bad filmmaker. Sure, he's made a ton of bad movies over the years, but it's obvious that the man has some amount of talent. In his earlier career, his movies were good. They varied in how good they were, but they still showed a lot of craftsmanship, skill, and intelligence. However, I'm not going to deny that movies like The Last Airbender, The Happening, After Earth, and The Lady in the Water are godawful. These movies range from boring as hell to unintentionally hilarious. It DOES appear that M. Night is digging himself out of the hole he put himself in. The Visit was decent and Split was actually pretty darn good. I'm hoping for the guy to continue to be successful, not just because he's a fellow Philadelphian, but because he actually TRIES in each one of his movies. He's not like Michael Bay or Seltzer Friedberg where they don't care at all about the quality of their films. It's obvious that Shyamalan is an avid lover of cinema ... more - phillysports

···································································

看来我有点仓促下了结论，因为玻璃真的很烂。—菲利普波特

Looks like I jumped to a conclusion a little bit because Glass absolutely sucked. - phillysports

···································································

让这个家伙休息一下吧。他的神秘惊悚片是同类中最好的。如果你考虑到《阿凡达》系列第一季持续了440分钟，而电影却持续了90分钟，同时又涵盖了完全相同的情节，那么每个人都会失败的，他不是一个伟大的幻想作家。但一个给我们带来了《第六感》、《牢不可破》、《标志》和《村庄》的人不可能是最差的导演之一。但他绝对应该被列入一个优秀导演名单，但最糟糕的失误。哇，《最后的气宗》是不是很糟糕

Give this guy a break. His mystery thrillers are the best of the genre.Everyone would have failed with "The Last Airbender", if you consider the first season of the series Avatar lasted about 440 minutes, and the movies lasts about 90 minutes while covering the exact same plot. And yeah, he is not too great as a fantasy writer. But a guy who brought us "The Sixth Sense", "Unbreakable", "Signs" and "The Village" simply can't be one of the worst directors. He would definitely deserve to be on a list about good directors with the worst slips though. Wow, was "The Last Airbender" bad... - Martin_Canine

···································································

M、 奈特·希亚玛兰有着高超的天赋弯曲技巧，无论他雇佣了多少优秀的演员，他们中的大多数最终都像外星人一样，不知道如何扮演人类，比如《发生》中的马克·沃伯格和《地球之后》中的威尔·史密斯。他改编的《阿凡达》系列电影是对所有影迷的侮辱，他的情节扭曲都是混蛋但老实说，他的一些电影真的很糟糕，它们真的很搞笑，像《发生在水里的女人》

M. Night Shyamalan has the great skill of talent-bending. No matter how many great actors he engages, most of them end up acting like aliens who don't know how to play humans (like Mark Wahlberg in "The Happening" and Will Smith in "After Earth"). His movie adaptation of the Avatar series was an insult to all fans, his plot twists are asspulls but honestly... some of his movies are actually so incredibly bad, they are really hilarious (Like The Happening and Lady in the Water)

···································································

我很喜欢《阿凡达》，当我听说真人版《阿凡达》的时候，我以为这是一个让世界各地的人都知道这部精彩节目的机会，但印度导演彻底毁了！这个角色一点也不像系列赛！你怎么能在一个1个半小时的抢钱工具里放4季的和蔼可亲？再说，他的电影都是情节扭曲的！

I loved avatar a lot. When I heard about the live action avatar I thought it was a chance for a lot of people from around the world to know about this amazing show. But the Indian director ruined completely! The character look nothing like the serie! And how was you supposed to fit 4 season of geniousness into a 1and a half hour money-grabbing tool?Besides, his movie is all about plot twist (all of it! )

···································································

它只代表了第一季的水，但仍然是一部糟糕的电影

It only represented the first season (water) but still, it's a bad movie. - Kid_ethinederland

···································································

好吧，他执导了《第六感》和《牢不可破》，但其他五部都很蠢，大多数时候都是被迫的，演员们从来没有把任何情感投入到这段经历中！从迹象到地球后，一切都只是一个大垃圾！…不，即使是一个垃圾也比标志更有尊严

Okay, he directed The Sixth Sense and Unbreakable but the other five where stupid, most of the times the twists are forced and the actors never really put any emotion into the experience! From Signs to After Earth it's all been just a big piece of crap!... No, even a piece of crap has more dignity than Signs.

···································································

只有第六感才是好的；而且它对任何新的人来说都是毁灭性的，因为它的结局是有史以来最著名的剧透！这些迹象都是有潜力的，直到真正愚蠢的人，牢不可破是极其迟钝和缓慢的。他所做的一切都说明了这一点

Only The Sixth Sense is good; and it's ruined to anyone new because it's ending is the most well-known spoiler ever! The Signs had potential until it took a turn for the really stupid, and Unbreakable is extremely dull and slow. Everything else he's done speaks for itself. - BKAllmighty

···································································

好吧，我真的认为他应该被除名。尽管十年前拍《阿凡达》时遭遇了灾难，但他确实进步了，成为了一个不错的电影导演。但我真的相信《符号》是一部好电影。他甚至一点都不差

Well, I actually do believe he should be removed on this list. Despite the disaster of making Avatar one decade ago, he really did improved to be a decent director of making Split.But I really do believe that Signs is a good film. He's not even a bad director at all.